Brief a case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words

Brief a - Case Study ExampleDespite the presence of a valid handgun permit the incumbent issued Washington a summons to show in court.The key issue is that of Melvin Washingtons interlocutory appeal in retaliation of the courts denial of his motion that demands that all evidence sight while the vehicle was searched be repressed. He states that the search was in direct violation of the Fourth Amendment of the US Constitution and also that of Article 1, Section 11 of the Indiana Constitution.On November 12, 2008, Washington was charged by the State for the possession of marijuana, as a Class A offense and a Class C infraction for not having fully functional headlights. On 29th April, 2009, Washington appealed to suppress the drugs found in his vehicle. This motion was denied by the court on the 18th of May, after an analysis of evidence and briefs from both(prenominal) parties. However the court accepted Washingtons interlocutory appeal in August.The justification for the bases of t he conclusiveness taken by the court is primarily focused on placing a paramount importance on officer safety. The action taken by Officer Reynolds was therefore relevant as he conducted a search for the weapon in order to ensure his safety.There are divergent opinions pertaining to the case broadly speaking because of the lack of a warrant obtained in order to search the vehicle when no prior suspiciousness was aroused and Washington has cooperated to the fullest. Hence there was no legitimate concern for the officers safety or each solid bases to believe if any crime was or had been conducted. Based on this notion the search was extralegal and hence the evidence it resulted in should have been